Thursday, August 19, 2010

Should the Kentucky Farm Bureau listen to moralistic lectures from a group called "W.E.N.C.H."?

A veritable cornucopia of left-wing groups, including the Kentucky "Fairness" Alliance, the ACLU, and a group (get this) called "W.E.N.C.H," along with some less exotic groups that really should know better, is trying to intimidate the Kentucky Farm Bureau into changing several of its policy positions, among them, its pro-life position and its position in support of traditional marriage.

The Farm Bureau and its 470,934 members need to tell these groups to mind their own business, whatever (and we do wonder, especially in the case of "W.E.N.C.H.") that may be.

HT: Page One

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

The Southern Critics: An Anthology

My favorite publisher is ISI Books. ISI itself (the "Intercollegiate Studies Institute") has manned the barricades in the defense of Western civilization with more enthusiasm than just about any other single entity, and ISI Books, their publishing arm, is probably the single most solid and stalwart publisher in what sometimes seems a losing fight. Their journals too are one of the things that makes my daily trip to the mailbox exciting. Modern Age, and the Intercollegiate Review are among the five or six journals I get that I depend upon for intellectual satisfaction.

I have several reviews in various stages of completion I need to post of their books, but rather than wait till I read them, I am going to start posting the publishers blurbs to these books as they are published until I finish the full reviews of some of them.

The thing that has provoked me to this is their latest release: The Southern Critics: An Anthology. Since reading At War with the Word, by R. V. Young (now editor of modern age), I have had an insatiable interest in the role of Southern writers in the history of literary criticism. One of the implicit themes in Young's book was the significant involvement of southern writers in the New Criticism of the early and mid-20th century.

The New Criticism refocused criticism on literary works themselves, away from what one new critic, W. K. Wimsatt, called the affective fallacy--that a literary work should be judged according to its subjective effect on the reader--and the intentional fallacy--that a works should be judged according the intention of the author. A work, they said, should be judged on its own merits, apart from these other considerations. A few of the New Critics took these ideas too far, but the movement as a whole resided squarely within the tradition of Western literature and still serves as a bane the postmodernist critics in our universities who, disdainful of Western culture in general, still can't totally stamp it out.

Robert Penn Warren, Donald Davidson, John Crowe Ransome, Allen Tate, and Cleanth Brooks, southerners all, were at the center of the New Criticism--in fact, were a necessary part of it.

Just go back and look at the influence just two of these had on English teaching: Brooks & Warren. The wrote what seem like countless textbooks on how to teach literature. Indeed, one wonders what other way there is to effectively teach literature than the way they did it. It certainly beats the current way of teaching literature, which consists primarily of doing something else.

Here is the publisher's blurb on this book:

In the early 1920s a collection of young Southerners at Vanderbilt University formed the literary group known as the Fugitives. Over the next few decades they and their followers would exert an enormous influence on the study of literature. Indeed, the "Southern Critics" included some of the most important American writers and critics of the twentieth century: Robert Penn Warren, Flannery O’Connor, John Crowe Ransom, Allen Tate, and Cleanth Brooks, to name just a few.

In The Southern Critics: An Anthology, editor Glenn C. Arbery gathers the most penetrating essays by these and other writers, bringing their significant contribution back into focus. Arbery’s enlightening commentary allows us to understand how the Southern Critics' concern for the history and culture of the South informed all their work—not just the landmark Agrarian manifesto I’ll Take My Stand (1930) but even their writings on literature and poetry, including their revolutionary "New Criticism."

Remarkably, the essays collected here speak to our time as much as to the Southern Critics' own. In the twenty-first century we recognize the prescience of their warnings about what would happen to art, leisure, and time itself when everything fell under the sway of the industrial model.

Do yourself a favor and visit ISI's books page.

Monday, August 16, 2010

What males and females are for

In the newest issue of Touchstone Magazine, Anthony Esolen puts the Supreme Court decision on California's Proposition 8 in perspective even before it happened. In his article, entitled "Sanctity & Matrimony: Ten Arguments in Defense of Marriage," Esolen writes,
The acceptance of homosexuality is predicated upon the assumption that male and female are not made for each other.
I had not thought of it this way before. But, of course, this is just a species of the larger problem of the abandonment of final causality: nothing is for anything. Nothing has any intrinsic purpose at all --except when you are a scientist and you forget yourself and start muttering about parts of things being for this or that despite your rejection of the same things outside your discipline.

In fact it is interesting that those who will talk about every other bodily organ being for something (a heart is "for" pumping blood, a kidney is "for" filtering the blood, etc.) will turn right around and deny that the sexual organs are for what they are obviously for (and what, by inference, they are not for).

This just underscores the vast divide that exists between those of us who consistently accept that there are intrinsic purposes in things (including all bodily organs), and those who inconsistently reject it.

Friday, August 13, 2010

Is there favoritism towards women in sports coverage?


Is it only my own impression or are readers of newspapers being pressured to pay more attention to women's sports? Every time you open a sports page, the coverage of women's althletics seem completely out of proportion to the actual interest in it. You feel like you should have an interest, even if you don't--that there's an implicit finger being wagged at you.

Well, turns out the coverage does appear to be out of alignment.

It's one thing to watch men sweat and grunt and spit, but another to watch women do it.

Nothing personal.

Thursday, August 12, 2010

P. Z. Myers: Not Understanding Even the Simple Things

P. Z. Myers thinks he’s starting to understand David Bentley Hart. Is it because he’s studied Hart’s work on the meaning of suffering in the context of the doctrine of evil as privatio boni? Has he read Hart’s comparison of Heidegger and St. Gregory of Nyssa’s ontology? Or maybe it’s more modest: maybe he’s studied up on the basic philosophic vocabulary used in the cosmological argument that had him completely baffled.

Nope. He’s read Hart’s new essay on Julian the Apostate, and he claims to have understood Hart’s worldview. But almost every claim in his post is flatly wrong.

Myers says that Hart has written “a column praising Julius the Apostate”, an article that not only praises him, but “heap[s] praise on him.” How he got this from Hart is a bit of a mystery. Here’s Hart’s judgment of him:
[W]hile he was a gifted ruler, his errors of judgment were legion, his hatred of the Christians often degenerated into childish spite, and he was destroyed more by callow egotism than by tragic hubris.
Myers adds that Hart “acknowledges” Julian’s intelligence. Here’s Hart on the subject of Julian’s intelligence:
Far from being any sort of rationalist, he was a particularly credulous religious enthusiast, who delighted in blood sacrifice, magic, astrology, and mystery; when he tried his hand at philosophy, the results were embarrassing.
Indeed, Hart claims that it is precisely Julian’s “naivete” that he finds interesting. There’s nothing particularly difficult about this essay: Hart doesn’t engage in much philosophy or theology at all. If Myers cannot even understand a whimsical essay that simply explicates the sensation of standing at a turning point in history where an old order is passing away, how credible is his claim to “tackle all the arguments for the existence of God"?

There are other silly falsehoods in Myer's post. Myers claims that Hart believes everything in the past was better, when Hart has written at length about the cruelty of the pre-Christian Classical world. Myers claims that the Middle Ages were a "trough" in terms of scientific progress, burdened by an "anti-scientific" Church, when in fact the Middle Ages were a time of great learning, sponsored by the Church; the Middle Ages were the time when science came into its own as a discipline (primarily because of the Aristotelian development in theology). The idea that the Middle Ages were a dark time for science or that the Church bore down on scientists is a well-known myth, and I think it not unlikely that Myers will soon be telling us that Christians believed in a flat earth. These falsehoods are simply Myers' historical ignorance on display.

Myers' central claim about Hart's piece is that Hart believes that:
Substance is unimportant, just so long as he believed. It's a strange world the modern defenders of religion live in, where they've given up hope in fighting for the specifics of their dogma, and are reduced to desperately hoping that someone somewhere will be nestled in a delusion of some kind.
Where Myers got this is a mystery. The claim that Hart doesn't believe in fighting for the specifics of dogma is absurd given Hart's well known track record of harshly criticizing other theologians over theological matters. Further, this claim contradicts Myers' own (atrociously misguided) summary of Hart's essay: Myers at least recognized that Hart "doesn't admire [Julian] for his views" (one of the very few propositions in Myers post that is correct). So where does the claim come from?

My own view is that he's just making it up. Myers has no concept of rigor for any kind of inquiry outside biology (and for all I know, not even in biology). He claims to attack every formulation of the arguments for the existence of God, yet he expresses dismay upon encountering the basic terminology. His description of Hart's assessment of Julian is directly contrary to Hart's own words. He thinks the Middle Ages were a dark time for science, overrun by an anti-scientific Church. And so on.

Which just gets me back to my original point: Myers shouldn't be taken seriously.

Putting things together in education

The following is the text of my "Letter from the Editor" in the new Classical Teacher magazine:

When my first son was young, I would come home from work and had would want me to pick him up. When I did, the first thing he did was to reach into my shirt pocket and grab whatever pen or mechanical pencil he would find there, at which point he would proceed to take it apart. Of course, being so young, he was not able to put them back together again. That was a job left for me.

One of the tendencies of modern education, is to take the discipline of education apart--and it doesn't do a very good job of putting it back together again.

I have spent more than a little time in my professional career dealing with public school education policy. I have served on various state education committees, including our state's Goals 2000 Committee, and the Character Education Committee. In all of these cases I have noticed the same tendency of wanting to take the education process apart in order to make it clearer to people when, in fact, it does exactly the opposite.

For example, every state has a set of education standards of some sort. If you go online, you can find them. But instead of clarifying things, they only make them more mysterious by ignoring the old educational disciplines--arithmetic, history, reading--in favor of long lists of discrete abstract skills. They have abstracted these skills from the whole disciplines of which they were once a part, and now ask professional educators to think of the education process in terms of hundreds of these isolated skills.

This tendency has even reached physical education. People taking degrees in physical education are apparently trained to emphasize the discrete skills of particular sports, so that children spend less time actually playing a sport, than training in the particular skills that were a part of these sports.

Instead of playing basketball, volleyball, or baseball, many physical education instructors break out little orange cones and try to mimic the individual physical movements that these sports once required of the player, but are now to be performed all by themselves, outside of the context of what you to be, in addition to good exercise, actually fun.

It is a tendency from the whole to the parts abstracted from the whole, with no acknowledgment that the parts benefited from being a part of the whole.

In the old system of classical education, language was taught using the classical trivium. Once a child learned how to decode and was reading English, he began his Latin study. Latin is a discipline which includes in it a whole range of skills: vocabulary, grammar, and the thinking skills involved in distinguishing between person and number, case and gender--not to mention the skills involved in such an organized and systematic study.

But in the early 20th century, when classical education was displaced by progressives and pragmatists intent on changing the purpose of schools toward more political and vocational purposes, Latin was first driven out of the elementary curriculum and forced to take refuge in high schools. It was eventually driven even from there.

Why do Latin when we can teach the skills that it taught so well in other forms? So schools tried to mimic all of the individual skills that were once packaged within the discipline of Latin. If you read books used in teachers colleges in the 1940s, you find that those in charge of training teachers were well aware of the plight they were in: of reconstructing the benefits of Latin without the benefit involved in actually teaching Latin.

Since that time, we have seen an endless parade of attempts to do the things Latin once did. Program after program, with limitless combinations of languages skills has tried to do what Latin once did. And it never seems to work very well.

The pens and pencils I had in my pocket when I came home worked quite well. But when my son took them apart, they became a lot less useful. I had to put them back together again in order for them to work properly.

If you are jaded by the endless variety of language arts programs that are now available to Christian educators, you might try going back to the favored system of language instruction the way it was before our educational system took it apart.

It worked a lot better.

Monday, August 09, 2010

Where is the Republican Party on a constitutional amendment to defend marriage?

Well, if anyone doubted that redefining words could have sweeping social consequences, we now have the Perry v. Schwarzenegger case as clear evidence that it does. The decision concluded that the state had no "rational interest" in clarifying the definition of marriage in Proposition 8, and so struck it down.

I will have a full analysis of this case later, but in the meantime it is interesting to read about the plans of David Boies and Theodore Olsen to take the case to the U. S. Supreme Court, where Anthony Kennedy, the likely swing vote in the case, awaits its reception with the reasoning he used in Bower v. Harwick, the case that struck down the Texas sodomy law.

Gay rights groups are wary of taking this to the high court, fearing a gay rights Waterloo, but I can't fathom why. It would appear likely right now that they have five votes to establish same-sex "marriage" as the law of the land.

The political question on this whole thing is where the Republicans are on this. Are they willing to revisit the idea of a constitutional amendment to right the cultural ship?

So far, we haven't heard anything from them.

Monday, August 02, 2010

Is monogamy natural to humans? Just ask a chimp

We have taken another specimen of evolutionary romanticism into captivity and have been conducting some logical experiments on it to see how it holds up. This one comes care of Christopher Ryan, who claims, care of CNN.com, that there is no reason to believe that monogamy is natural to humans.

His argument could count as evidence that rationality is not natural to humans.
Seismic cultural shifts about 10,000 years ago rendered the true story of human sexuality so subversive and threatening that for centuries, it has been silenced by religious authorities, pathologized by physicians, studiously ignored by scientists and covered up by moralizing therapists.
We're still trying to piece together the succession of Egyptian dynasties, but Ryan knows about specific cultural shifts 10,000 years ago. Hmmm. Apparently, Ryan has never heard the term "prehistoric."

Most "mainstream therapists," he says,
insist that long-term sexual monogamy is "normal," while the curiosity and novelty-seeking inherent in human sexuality are signs of pathology. ... This is a problem because there is no reason to believe monogamy comes naturally to human beings. In fact, for millions of years, evolutionary forces have cultivated human libido to the point where ours is arguably the most sexual species on Earth.
Notice what's going on here: We talk about all the evidence against marriage we can derive from early human society, about which we know little, and ignore all the evidence in favor of it from later human society, about which we know a lot. And the one thing we know about societies for which we do have histories is that marriage in some form is almost omnipresent.

Then, of course, we assume that primitive practices are somehow more representative of what human nature really is than more recent civilized practices:
Research from primatology, anthropology, anatomy and psychology points to the same conclusion: A nonpossessive, gregarious sexuality was the human norm until the rise of agriculture and private property just 10,000 years ago, about 5 percent of anatomically modern humans' existence on Earth.
And if the behavior of early humans is to be considered authoritative in determining what proper human behavior is to be, then going even further back ought to be even more instructive:
The two primate species closest to us lend strong -- if blush-inducing -- support to this vision. Ovulating female chimps have intercourse dozens of times per day, with most or all of the willing males, and bonobos famously enjoy frequent group sex that leaves everyone relaxed and conflict-free.
Well, gee, if chimps and bonobos do it, what are we waiting for?

I suppose we could just continue going back through the evolutionary chronology to see what we were doing when we were doing the bacterial backstroke in the primordial slime and come up with some great dating tips.

But we better not give Ryan any ideas.

Finally there is the appeal to anatomical romanticism, which we will have to forgo including here since this is a nice family blog. Suffice it to say it is not pretty. But the gist of his argument is that, if you look at certain male body organs, they are bigger than these same certain body organs among primates, and this is clearly indicative that men are meant to run around copulating freely with as many females as they desire.

Ryan's argument has all the intellectual sophistication of George Carlin's argument that since the human index finger is the same size as the human nostril, it was obviously designed for nose-picking.

It is also interesting that, whenever you invoke any kind of intrinsic nature or purpose to explain any natural thing, you are told by Darwinists that this thinking is a vestige of the old Aristotelian scholasticism, and that final and formal causes were abandoned during the scientific revolution. But then they import them in the back door to implicitly justify their arguments about what human anatomical features say about our natures.

If Aristotelianism is dead, the why are they talking about the inherent purposes of body parts?

If you want more comic relief at the expense of human nature, you can consult Ryan's book, Sex at Dawn: The Prehistoric Origins of Modern Sexuality.

Saturday, July 31, 2010

Reflections on American Idol possibly going off the air

Well, according to some reports, the show "American Idol" may be coming to an end. This is unfortunate, since I have never seen the show that so many people talk about, and I was looking forward to continuing to be a non-viewer for years to come. So it comes as a hard blow to know that I now will be unable to continue to refrain from watching this great pop cultural spectacle.

But at least I can continue to be a non-viewer of other television shows of similar importance, such as "Dancing with the Stars," "CSI," and (probably my favorite show not to watch) "Desperate Housewives."

In fact, it is probably a good thing that "American Idol" may be going off the air, since it reduces the number of shows I don't watch, giving me more time not to watch others.

So many programs not worth watching, so little time not to watch them ...

Ann Rice: "I quit being a human"

Anne Rice who became famous for her vampire novels before announcing she had become Catholic, now says she simply refuses to perpetuate the charade of being human:
It's simply impossible for me to “belong” to this quarrelsome, hostile, disputatious, and deservedly infamous group.
She is now seeking other species with which she can join in solidarity (preferably herbivores) to promote peace and tranquility, and teach the world to sing in perfect harmony.

Oh, wait ... Hold on.

Actually, Rice announced that she is renouncing Christianity because it is quarrelsome, hostile, and disputatious. I don't know how I could have become so confused.

Nevermind.

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Will this health care bureaucracy be more efficient?

How Obamacare works:

Now, raise your hand if you think this is going to make our health care system more efficient...

Some groups are "green" in more ways that one

Like I've always said: Follow the money. There are big profits to be made in green technology, and the multi-national corporations aren't leaving anything to chance. And many Green groups, who purport to be independent voices on environmental issues, may well be on the take.

And why is it that the President of BP, yes that BP, is on the advisory board of the Earth Institute?

Check out the Times Higher Education Supplement for an eye-opening exposé.

HT: Bishop Hill