According to reports today, Stumbo is going to stop shooting the Governor in the front, but Republican officials have declared they are not going to stop shooting the Governor in the back.
Those Disloyalists. They're so hard to please.
Bill Stone, former Jefferson County Republican Chairman, asked a great question in his radio debate with Jack Richardson, current Jefferson County Republican Chairman and one of the leaders of the Disloyalists. The debate took place on the other day on Front Page with Sue Wiley in Lexington. "What are you going to do," asked Stone, "if Gov. Fletcher wins the Republican nomination? Are you going to support him?"
Richardson tried to dance around an answer, but finally said he would.
Then Stone ran him all the way through: "Are you going to have any credibility at that point?"
Of course, Richardson couldn't answer this one. But this is the position Republican officials find themselves in: they digging themselves a hole they will not be able to dig themselves out of.
Behind all this is the Republican puppetmaster himself: Mitch McConnell. If this is a display of his fabled political skills, there may have to be a reassessment when this is all over.
Friday, August 25, 2006
Thursday, August 24, 2006
Is It Time for the Republican Disloyalists to Lay Down Their Weapons?
Gov. Fletcher appears to have succeeded in resolving the battle with the state's leading Democrat. It is significant that he has done this almost completely without the help of his own party, which left him in the lurch by abandoning him from the outset. Battling Stumbo is hard enough; doing it alone and prevailing is no mean achievment.
So what does this mean for the Governor's problems within his own party? Maybe the Governor could now proceed with settlement discussions with the Disloyalist Republicans who have been shooting the Governor in the back while Stumbo has been firing from the front.
For all practical purposes, the Disloyalists have been in league with Democrats against the Governor. Now that Stumbo has withdrawn his forces, will the Disloyalists lay down their weapons?
So what does this mean for the Governor's problems within his own party? Maybe the Governor could now proceed with settlement discussions with the Disloyalist Republicans who have been shooting the Governor in the back while Stumbo has been firing from the front.
For all practical purposes, the Disloyalists have been in league with Democrats against the Governor. Now that Stumbo has withdrawn his forces, will the Disloyalists lay down their weapons?
Charges Against Governor Dismissed
The Courier-Journal is reporting that special judge David Melcher has dismised the charges against Gov. Fletcher "without prejudice", meaning they can't be brought again.
Wednesday, August 23, 2006
Why evangelicals can't write
Great article in the new Credenda Agenda (issue topic: Flannery O'Connor) on why evangelicals can't write: http://www.credenda.org/issues/18-2liturgia.php. I've never heard this thesis before, and I don't know if Zwingli's the real culprit, but his main point is right on.
Monday, July 31, 2006
Ivory Tower Irrationalities
The following is my response to Brian Cooney's guest opinion in the Danville Advocate Messenger, "What does 'God, Family, Country' mean?". Cooney's piece appeared on July 24, my response appeared on July 25. Cooney is a professor of Philosophy at Centre College.
Dear Editor,
In his article, "What does 'God, Family, Country' mean," Centre College professor Brian Cooney comments on the words he says he saw at a local Republican group's booth at the county fair. He says of these three words--'God', 'family', and 'country', "I've been wondering what the words mean, and how they are connected."
Cooney then launches into a somewhat bizarre, pseudo-Freudian analysis of these words and their connection to one another, saying that a whole range of conservative political positions, including positions on issues like minimum wage and estate taxes, are somehow tied together by an extremist, patriarchal view of the family. The analysis is so outrageous (to borrow an expression from George Orwell) that only an intellectual could believe it.
Now if you went out on Main Street and asked average people what these terms meant, they would have no trouble telling you. An average person could tell you what the words 'God', 'family', and 'country' meant without any hesitation. So why does Cooney, a philosophy professor at a well-respected college, have trouble making sense of them? Is the air just thin up there in the top floor office of whatever campus building he's in?
He and his ivory tower friends really should get out more.
I have another theory of the connection between these words, and why they would be be emphasized in the rhetoric of a modern political party. Maybe it's because there is a whole class of people like Cooney who populate our cultural and governmental institutions who've completely lost touch with reality and have forgotten what basic, everyday terms like 'God', 'family', and 'country' mean, and therefore are left having to spin exotic theories about them.
Maybe these political groups stress these terms in order to jerk the feet of people like Cooney back down to earth again.
Dear Editor,
In his article, "What does 'God, Family, Country' mean," Centre College professor Brian Cooney comments on the words he says he saw at a local Republican group's booth at the county fair. He says of these three words--'God', 'family', and 'country', "I've been wondering what the words mean, and how they are connected."
Cooney then launches into a somewhat bizarre, pseudo-Freudian analysis of these words and their connection to one another, saying that a whole range of conservative political positions, including positions on issues like minimum wage and estate taxes, are somehow tied together by an extremist, patriarchal view of the family. The analysis is so outrageous (to borrow an expression from George Orwell) that only an intellectual could believe it.
Now if you went out on Main Street and asked average people what these terms meant, they would have no trouble telling you. An average person could tell you what the words 'God', 'family', and 'country' meant without any hesitation. So why does Cooney, a philosophy professor at a well-respected college, have trouble making sense of them? Is the air just thin up there in the top floor office of whatever campus building he's in?
He and his ivory tower friends really should get out more.
I have another theory of the connection between these words, and why they would be be emphasized in the rhetoric of a modern political party. Maybe it's because there is a whole class of people like Cooney who populate our cultural and governmental institutions who've completely lost touch with reality and have forgotten what basic, everyday terms like 'God', 'family', and 'country' mean, and therefore are left having to spin exotic theories about them.
Maybe these political groups stress these terms in order to jerk the feet of people like Cooney back down to earth again.
Monday, July 24, 2006
Be Concerned Republicans. Be Very Concerned
Fletcher critics in the state Republican Party establishment launched a counterattack last week against accusations that the Party was shooting its wounded in attacking rather than defending a sitting Governor of their own party. Ted Jackson's remarks in Thursday's Lexington Herald-Leader ("Fletcher's GOP Critics not Disloyal") initially included an incorrect assertion that Richard Nixon was president in 1976, but the mistake turned out to be an editorial error by the Herald.
The Nixon gaffe was the Herald's, but the rest of the article's shortcomings (unless the Herald editors really did the piece up) are entirely Jackson's.
Jackson, who had defended Jack Richardson's fragging of Fletcher in the Courier-Journal a couple of weeks ago, was obviously stung by criticisms that shooting at your own troops was disloyal.
Jackson made clear that the Disloyalists are very uncomfortable with the characterization that they are, in fact, disloyal. It's perfectly fine, he argues, to fire on your own troops--and to abandon them on the field when they are fired upon by the enemy. And it is unfair for anyone to call this practice disloyal. In fact, argues Jackson, to undermine your own leaders is perfectly consistent with the principles of the Republican Party.
"There is nothing," he says, "wrong with Republicans questioning whether Gov. Ernie Fletcher represents our best chance for winning again in 2007."
Furthermore, he argues, it is inappropriate for the Governor's defenders to call upon fellow Republicans to be loyal. And not only that, but to point out that undermining members of your own party by joining their enemies from the Other Party and shooting at them too is bad because it makes the Disloyalists feel guilty about themselves.
"It is dead wrong for Fletcher and his apologists to attempt to use guilt to insulate his administration."
This is the defense of the Disloyalists.
First, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that firing on your troops is disloyal. It just is. You can characterize it however you want, but when your own officials--whom you have helped to put in the places they are--have bullet holes in their back from bullits you fired, then, guess what? You're disloyal.
Secondly, when you abandon these same officials in the face of a political onslaught by the likes of Greg Stumbo, and stand there in silence and watch it happen without lifting a finger, and then criticize him for not handling a situation that was made worse by your own inaction, then you're disloyal.
Finally, when you turn around and find yourself being criticized by other Republicans for being disloyal, and tell them that they're acting inappropriately, then, well, you have obviously lost your grip on reality.
Jackson apparently thinks it's completely acceptable to be disloyal, but it is wrong to encourage other people to be loyal. Furthermore, it's not fair to make he and his fellow Disloyalists feel bad about this.
Be concerned Republicans. Be very concerned.
But the most curious of Jackson's arguments is this one: What Kentucky Republican leaders are doing right now in regard to Fletcher is no different that what Ronald Reagan did when he challenged Gerald Ford for the 1976 Presidential nomination.
"In 1976," says Jackson, "a Republican from California challenged a sitting Republican president for their party's nomination. That man from California had concerns about the direction his fellow Republican was taking the party and the nation. No one could challenge his GOP credentials. Ronald Wilson Reagan had the right to ask the question, to spur the debate. That same debate must take place in Kentucky right now."
Arguing against the 11th Commandment by invoking the name of its author? Bad choice, Ted.
Let's get a few things straight here. First of all, Reagan was challenging Ford on the basis of political principles: Ford was a moderate; Reagan was a conservative. Secondly, Reagan was using the commonly acknowledged processes of the Party to do it: he challenged him in an election.
But that's not what's going on here. No one has announced a challenge of Fletcher. There's no primary going on. All that's going on is sniping.
As to the first point, what aspect of Fletcher's political principles are people like Jackson and Richardson challenging? Do they disagree with Fletcher's political principles and policies? If so, which ones? His stand on abortion? His stand on fiscal restraint? His stand on seat belts? Which one?
As to the second point, it is an entirely different thing to challange an incumbent in your own party in a fair election than it is to criticize him openly when there is no election going on and no candidates of his own party running against him--and an opposition party out there just asking to be beat because it has no candidate and little money.
No one thinks that running against an incumbent is disloyal. It may not be good for the Party in certain circumstances, and it may be unwise for the challenger. But when comments are made in a primary challenge, there's no issue of disloyalty when candidates make criticisms. But Jackson is not a candidate, nor is Richardson.
These two points ought to take care of any comparison between the author of the 11th Commandment and current state Party leaders who are ignoring it.
Then, there is the more general matter of trying to draft Reagan into the Disloyalists' cause.
Oh, but the political memory of the Disloyalist is so short. Jackson's attempt to invoke the name of Reagan is even more absurd when you consider what the argument against Reagan was in 1976 (and in 1980).
The argument against Reagan's candidacy was this: that he was unelectable. He was too conservative. Remember?
Jackson and the Disloyalists apparently forgot this--or chose not to remember it. And what is the argument they are using against Fletcher now? That he is unelectable. In other words, the same argument is being used against Fletcher now that was used--not against Ford, but against Reagan--and somehow Jackson thinks he sees an analogy between Fletcher and ... Ford!
As I mentioned in a previous column ("The Loyalty Gap"--see below), the Democrats would never let this happen in their own party. They know the value of loyalty. If Republicans don't learn this lesson, their political days are numbered.
The new Kentucky Republican political ethos appears to be this: every man for himself.
I like the 11th Commandment much better.
The Nixon gaffe was the Herald's, but the rest of the article's shortcomings (unless the Herald editors really did the piece up) are entirely Jackson's.
Jackson, who had defended Jack Richardson's fragging of Fletcher in the Courier-Journal a couple of weeks ago, was obviously stung by criticisms that shooting at your own troops was disloyal.
Jackson made clear that the Disloyalists are very uncomfortable with the characterization that they are, in fact, disloyal. It's perfectly fine, he argues, to fire on your own troops--and to abandon them on the field when they are fired upon by the enemy. And it is unfair for anyone to call this practice disloyal. In fact, argues Jackson, to undermine your own leaders is perfectly consistent with the principles of the Republican Party.
"There is nothing," he says, "wrong with Republicans questioning whether Gov. Ernie Fletcher represents our best chance for winning again in 2007."
Furthermore, he argues, it is inappropriate for the Governor's defenders to call upon fellow Republicans to be loyal. And not only that, but to point out that undermining members of your own party by joining their enemies from the Other Party and shooting at them too is bad because it makes the Disloyalists feel guilty about themselves.
"It is dead wrong for Fletcher and his apologists to attempt to use guilt to insulate his administration."
This is the defense of the Disloyalists.
First, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that firing on your troops is disloyal. It just is. You can characterize it however you want, but when your own officials--whom you have helped to put in the places they are--have bullet holes in their back from bullits you fired, then, guess what? You're disloyal.
Secondly, when you abandon these same officials in the face of a political onslaught by the likes of Greg Stumbo, and stand there in silence and watch it happen without lifting a finger, and then criticize him for not handling a situation that was made worse by your own inaction, then you're disloyal.
Finally, when you turn around and find yourself being criticized by other Republicans for being disloyal, and tell them that they're acting inappropriately, then, well, you have obviously lost your grip on reality.
Jackson apparently thinks it's completely acceptable to be disloyal, but it is wrong to encourage other people to be loyal. Furthermore, it's not fair to make he and his fellow Disloyalists feel bad about this.
Be concerned Republicans. Be very concerned.
But the most curious of Jackson's arguments is this one: What Kentucky Republican leaders are doing right now in regard to Fletcher is no different that what Ronald Reagan did when he challenged Gerald Ford for the 1976 Presidential nomination.
"In 1976," says Jackson, "a Republican from California challenged a sitting Republican president for their party's nomination. That man from California had concerns about the direction his fellow Republican was taking the party and the nation. No one could challenge his GOP credentials. Ronald Wilson Reagan had the right to ask the question, to spur the debate. That same debate must take place in Kentucky right now."
Arguing against the 11th Commandment by invoking the name of its author? Bad choice, Ted.
Let's get a few things straight here. First of all, Reagan was challenging Ford on the basis of political principles: Ford was a moderate; Reagan was a conservative. Secondly, Reagan was using the commonly acknowledged processes of the Party to do it: he challenged him in an election.
But that's not what's going on here. No one has announced a challenge of Fletcher. There's no primary going on. All that's going on is sniping.
As to the first point, what aspect of Fletcher's political principles are people like Jackson and Richardson challenging? Do they disagree with Fletcher's political principles and policies? If so, which ones? His stand on abortion? His stand on fiscal restraint? His stand on seat belts? Which one?
As to the second point, it is an entirely different thing to challange an incumbent in your own party in a fair election than it is to criticize him openly when there is no election going on and no candidates of his own party running against him--and an opposition party out there just asking to be beat because it has no candidate and little money.
No one thinks that running against an incumbent is disloyal. It may not be good for the Party in certain circumstances, and it may be unwise for the challenger. But when comments are made in a primary challenge, there's no issue of disloyalty when candidates make criticisms. But Jackson is not a candidate, nor is Richardson.
These two points ought to take care of any comparison between the author of the 11th Commandment and current state Party leaders who are ignoring it.
Then, there is the more general matter of trying to draft Reagan into the Disloyalists' cause.
Oh, but the political memory of the Disloyalist is so short. Jackson's attempt to invoke the name of Reagan is even more absurd when you consider what the argument against Reagan was in 1976 (and in 1980).
The argument against Reagan's candidacy was this: that he was unelectable. He was too conservative. Remember?
Jackson and the Disloyalists apparently forgot this--or chose not to remember it. And what is the argument they are using against Fletcher now? That he is unelectable. In other words, the same argument is being used against Fletcher now that was used--not against Ford, but against Reagan--and somehow Jackson thinks he sees an analogy between Fletcher and ... Ford!
As I mentioned in a previous column ("The Loyalty Gap"--see below), the Democrats would never let this happen in their own party. They know the value of loyalty. If Republicans don't learn this lesson, their political days are numbered.
The new Kentucky Republican political ethos appears to be this: every man for himself.
I like the 11th Commandment much better.
Saturday, July 22, 2006
Mistake was Herald's, Not Jackson's
The mistake discussed in yesterday's post on Ted Jackson's Herald-Leader column defending Republican opposition to Flether turns out to have originated not with Jackson, but with the Herald, according to David Adams on a comment on the previous post. We are trying to confirm this with the Herald, but we thought, in consideration to Jackson, that we would say it prominently now.
The column asserted that Richard Nixon was president in 1976, when, in fact, Gerald Ford was president at that time. The column was printed in the Herald with the Nixon comment in it. It was also that way on the Herald's online edition until it was taken off in the middle of the day yesterday. According to one of the comments on the previous post, it was also run in the Courier-Journal without the Nixon reference.
There are plenty of problems with the arguments in Jackson's piece, but, apparently, the assertion that Nixon was president in 1976 is not one of them.
There will be a fuller critique of Jackson's piece posted here on Monday.
Tune in.
The column asserted that Richard Nixon was president in 1976, when, in fact, Gerald Ford was president at that time. The column was printed in the Herald with the Nixon comment in it. It was also that way on the Herald's online edition until it was taken off in the middle of the day yesterday. According to one of the comments on the previous post, it was also run in the Courier-Journal without the Nixon reference.
There are plenty of problems with the arguments in Jackson's piece, but, apparently, the assertion that Nixon was president in 1976 is not one of them.
There will be a fuller critique of Jackson's piece posted here on Monday.
Tune in.
Friday, July 21, 2006
Fletcher Critic Gets History Wrong
In his column in yesterday's Lexington Herald-Leader, Ted Jackson, a proment critic of Gov. Ernie Fletcher, compared the current rebellion of Republican Party leaders against their own party's sitting governor to Reagan's opposition to Richard M. Nixon in 1976. Here are the words from his article:
There's only one problem. Richard M. Nixon was not president in 1976. Nixon resigned in 1974. The Presidency was held at that time by Gerald Ford, Nixon's Vice President, who assumed office after Nixon's resignation.
Maybe that is why the reference mysteriously disappeared today on the Herald-Leader's website. The passage now reads without the reference to Nixon, although the print version contained it.
This error would be fairly unremarkable under normal circumstances. After all, we all make mistakes. But the error was made in an argument discussing Fletcher's alleged incompetence in office, and relies on the analogy he tries to draw from a challenge by Reagan of Nixon that never actually happened.
If you're arguing that someone else is incompetent, you'd better have your own house in order.
What are we to make of Republicans who question the competence of Gov. Fletcher who don't even know who the president of the United States was in 1976--particularly when the president was from their own Party?!!!
Jackson's problem is further exacerbated by the fact that his whole argument is based on a mistaken belief about who was president. His argument about Fletcher clearly assumes Nixon was president in 1976.
Maybe we should all be very concerned about the competence of the Republican Disloyalists sniping at their governor. Maybe their current leaders should think about stepping down and letting someone else run their little Rebellion.
Wait a minute. Haven't we heard this same argument somewhere before?
In 1976, a Republican from California challenged a sitting Republican president, Richard M. Nixon, for their party's nomination. That man from California had concerns about the direction his fellow Republican was taking the party and the nation. No one could challenge his GOP credentials. Ronald Wilson Reagan had the right to ask the question, to spur the debate. That same debate must take place in Kentucky right now.
There's only one problem. Richard M. Nixon was not president in 1976. Nixon resigned in 1974. The Presidency was held at that time by Gerald Ford, Nixon's Vice President, who assumed office after Nixon's resignation.
Maybe that is why the reference mysteriously disappeared today on the Herald-Leader's website. The passage now reads without the reference to Nixon, although the print version contained it.
This error would be fairly unremarkable under normal circumstances. After all, we all make mistakes. But the error was made in an argument discussing Fletcher's alleged incompetence in office, and relies on the analogy he tries to draw from a challenge by Reagan of Nixon that never actually happened.
If you're arguing that someone else is incompetent, you'd better have your own house in order.
What are we to make of Republicans who question the competence of Gov. Fletcher who don't even know who the president of the United States was in 1976--particularly when the president was from their own Party?!!!
Jackson's problem is further exacerbated by the fact that his whole argument is based on a mistaken belief about who was president. His argument about Fletcher clearly assumes Nixon was president in 1976.
Maybe we should all be very concerned about the competence of the Republican Disloyalists sniping at their governor. Maybe their current leaders should think about stepping down and letting someone else run their little Rebellion.
Wait a minute. Haven't we heard this same argument somewhere before?
Wednesday, July 19, 2006
Stay Away Fools, 'Cause Love Rules at UofL
If you see a faded sign on the side of the road that says “fifteen miles to the University of Louisville,” you'll be directed toward a university whose board of trustees recently voted to provide taxpayer-funded domestic partner benefits to its unmarried employees with live-in sexual partners.
While the university is in the midst of these sweeping changes, it might want to consider a name change that more adequately characterizes the school under its new policy, and we’ve got just the thing: "The Love Shack." Given the popularity of the song of that name, it would be more nationally recognizable than its present title, and would have a greater attraction for the kind of prospective employees to which it now says it would like to appeal.
In a recent article in the Courier-Journal, Bill Stone, a UofL trustee who claims to be a conservative, said that without such a policy the university would restrict its "opportunities to attract all kinds of folks."
It seems unlikely that the "folks" the university now wants to attract will be hopping in their Chryslers and setting sail for UofL just because of the new policy. (This is, after all, the Volvo crowd we're talking about here). But even if they did head down the highway, looking for Louisville’s academic love getaway, how will the new policy be viewed by other kinds of "folks"--"folks" who aren't looking for a place to work (or a place to send their children) that encourages unmarried live-in heterosexual and homosexual relationships among its employees?
What is UofL's message to these “folks”?
"Stay away fools, 'cause love rules" at the University of Louisville.
In reality (a concept not terribly popular at funky little schools like UofL—or, apparently, among their trustees), the new policy is likely to alienate as many people as it attracts—among both prospective staff and students. The folks “lining up just to get down” are likely to be no more numerous than those who decided not to get in line in the first place.
As the policies of public institutions like UofL stray further and further away from the moral convictions of the taxpayers who are asked to support them, officials in control of those institutions cannot reasonably expect to bang on the door of the General Assembly, with a budget as big as a whale, and demand that legislators ask their constituents to hurry up and bring their jukebox money to pay for it.
This is why the controversy over UofL's policy is now as hot as an oven:
If taxpayers should expect anything, they ought at least to expect the institutions they support not to actively undermine their own values.
"I also want to make it clear," the “conservative” Stone went on, "this is not an endorsement of gay marriage or any of the other lightning issues."
Not so fast. Put all the glitter on it you want, that’s exactly what this decision is.
For years our cultural institutions have encouraged marriage. They have done this because there has been a cultural consensus on one simple fact—a consensus that still predominates despite the attempts of institutions like UofL to ignore it: marriage is good for society. If there is one fact that social science has established over the course of its existence, it is this one.
You can believe what you want to about non-marital, live-in relationships—same-sex or otherwise. You may think they're a Cosmic Thing. But the evidence they are good for society is slim to none, and when it comes to the consequences for children, that’s definitely not where it’s at.
Stone has obviously found in the University of Louisville Board of Trustees a little ol’ place where he can get together with others who see it as responsible to use taxpayer dollars to undermine marriage. We’re quite confident that the whole shack shimmies when Stone and his liberal friends bat these issues around and around and around as they make policy for the university.
Stone has the right to say anything he wants to. But when he starts lip synching the gay rights agenda, he really should be more careful in portraying it as "conservative". If marriage isn't one of those things conservatives are trying to conserve, then there's very little point in being one.
© 2006 by Martin Cothran. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be published without the express written consent of the author. These comments are the personal opinions of the author and should not be interpreted as representing the official opinion of any other persons or organizations.
This piece appears in today's Louisville Courier-Journal online opinion page.
While the university is in the midst of these sweeping changes, it might want to consider a name change that more adequately characterizes the school under its new policy, and we’ve got just the thing: "The Love Shack." Given the popularity of the song of that name, it would be more nationally recognizable than its present title, and would have a greater attraction for the kind of prospective employees to which it now says it would like to appeal.
In a recent article in the Courier-Journal, Bill Stone, a UofL trustee who claims to be a conservative, said that without such a policy the university would restrict its "opportunities to attract all kinds of folks."
It seems unlikely that the "folks" the university now wants to attract will be hopping in their Chryslers and setting sail for UofL just because of the new policy. (This is, after all, the Volvo crowd we're talking about here). But even if they did head down the highway, looking for Louisville’s academic love getaway, how will the new policy be viewed by other kinds of "folks"--"folks" who aren't looking for a place to work (or a place to send their children) that encourages unmarried live-in heterosexual and homosexual relationships among its employees?
What is UofL's message to these “folks”?
"Stay away fools, 'cause love rules" at the University of Louisville.
In reality (a concept not terribly popular at funky little schools like UofL—or, apparently, among their trustees), the new policy is likely to alienate as many people as it attracts—among both prospective staff and students. The folks “lining up just to get down” are likely to be no more numerous than those who decided not to get in line in the first place.
As the policies of public institutions like UofL stray further and further away from the moral convictions of the taxpayers who are asked to support them, officials in control of those institutions cannot reasonably expect to bang on the door of the General Assembly, with a budget as big as a whale, and demand that legislators ask their constituents to hurry up and bring their jukebox money to pay for it.
This is why the controversy over UofL's policy is now as hot as an oven:
If taxpayers should expect anything, they ought at least to expect the institutions they support not to actively undermine their own values.
"I also want to make it clear," the “conservative” Stone went on, "this is not an endorsement of gay marriage or any of the other lightning issues."
Not so fast. Put all the glitter on it you want, that’s exactly what this decision is.
For years our cultural institutions have encouraged marriage. They have done this because there has been a cultural consensus on one simple fact—a consensus that still predominates despite the attempts of institutions like UofL to ignore it: marriage is good for society. If there is one fact that social science has established over the course of its existence, it is this one.
You can believe what you want to about non-marital, live-in relationships—same-sex or otherwise. You may think they're a Cosmic Thing. But the evidence they are good for society is slim to none, and when it comes to the consequences for children, that’s definitely not where it’s at.
Stone has obviously found in the University of Louisville Board of Trustees a little ol’ place where he can get together with others who see it as responsible to use taxpayer dollars to undermine marriage. We’re quite confident that the whole shack shimmies when Stone and his liberal friends bat these issues around and around and around as they make policy for the university.
Stone has the right to say anything he wants to. But when he starts lip synching the gay rights agenda, he really should be more careful in portraying it as "conservative". If marriage isn't one of those things conservatives are trying to conserve, then there's very little point in being one.
© 2006 by Martin Cothran. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be published without the express written consent of the author. These comments are the personal opinions of the author and should not be interpreted as representing the official opinion of any other persons or organizations.
This piece appears in today's Louisville Courier-Journal online opinion page.
Tuesday, July 18, 2006
The Fairness Alliance Needs to Get It's Own House in Order
Liberals love to feel morally superior. One way you can see this tendency in action is when they call upon other people to live up to standards they themselves are unwilling to abide by. They are morally superior, so why should they have to abide by the same rules everyone else does?
So here comes the Kentucky Fairness Alliance, an organization devoted to minimizing the moral implications of sexuality, yet full of its own preachy moralism, lecturing everyone else, once again, on how to act. Predictably, the Fairness Alliance, along with the Democratic Party, are calling for State Sen. Dick Roeding to resign. Why? Because he said bad things about homosexuals.
Roeding, whose district covers part of the Northern Kentucky area, said that UofL's recent decision to give benefits to live-in sexual partners of their employees that it was "repulsive." He also said that it would attract the "wrong kind of people" to the state. Added to that was his reference to gays as "queers" on the Louiville's Francene Show yesterday.
"He spoke," said state Democratic Party Chairman Jerry Lundergan, "in tongues of hatred, bigotry, vulgarity, and that's not acceptable."
Okay. Well, let's first point out that gays call each other "queer" all the time. In fact, they have created a whole academic discipline using the term in its title. It's called "Queer Theory." Needless to say, it's as bogus as Gender Studies and Black Studies from an academic perspective, but it apparently makes a handful of people who are obsessed with exotic forms of sexuality feel good.
Just try a web search and check it out.
At the same time, that's not an excuse to call names. The argument--that because a group of people use a term of themeselves, therefore it's okay for others to do it--does not work, for example, with the "N" word.
So the bottom line is that the remarks were over the top. Not only that, but they weren't nice--Or, to speak in the Christian language we are, unfortunately, fast losing, the remarks were not charitable. You just shouldn't call people names.
But while we're talking about fairness and the problem of some people calling other people names, why shouldn't the Fairness Alliance be held accountable for its past remarks?
The Fairness Alliance has been calling people names for years. How many times have we heard conservative religious people referred to as "bigots" or "religious fanatics" simply because they're religious beliefs lead them to belief that homosexuality is wrong?
And it isn't only the Fairness Alliance that violates the no-name-calling policy on a regular basis. The media is just as bad. They speak in tongues equally hateful, bigoted, and vulgar, but apparently that is just fine with people Like Jerry Lundergan.
If the Fairness Alliance thinks name calling is wrong, and that saying bad things about people they disagree with is inappropriate, then what about their own behavior.
Physician, heal thyself.
So here comes the Kentucky Fairness Alliance, an organization devoted to minimizing the moral implications of sexuality, yet full of its own preachy moralism, lecturing everyone else, once again, on how to act. Predictably, the Fairness Alliance, along with the Democratic Party, are calling for State Sen. Dick Roeding to resign. Why? Because he said bad things about homosexuals.
Roeding, whose district covers part of the Northern Kentucky area, said that UofL's recent decision to give benefits to live-in sexual partners of their employees that it was "repulsive." He also said that it would attract the "wrong kind of people" to the state. Added to that was his reference to gays as "queers" on the Louiville's Francene Show yesterday.
"He spoke," said state Democratic Party Chairman Jerry Lundergan, "in tongues of hatred, bigotry, vulgarity, and that's not acceptable."
Okay. Well, let's first point out that gays call each other "queer" all the time. In fact, they have created a whole academic discipline using the term in its title. It's called "Queer Theory." Needless to say, it's as bogus as Gender Studies and Black Studies from an academic perspective, but it apparently makes a handful of people who are obsessed with exotic forms of sexuality feel good.
Just try a web search and check it out.
At the same time, that's not an excuse to call names. The argument--that because a group of people use a term of themeselves, therefore it's okay for others to do it--does not work, for example, with the "N" word.
So the bottom line is that the remarks were over the top. Not only that, but they weren't nice--Or, to speak in the Christian language we are, unfortunately, fast losing, the remarks were not charitable. You just shouldn't call people names.
But while we're talking about fairness and the problem of some people calling other people names, why shouldn't the Fairness Alliance be held accountable for its past remarks?
The Fairness Alliance has been calling people names for years. How many times have we heard conservative religious people referred to as "bigots" or "religious fanatics" simply because they're religious beliefs lead them to belief that homosexuality is wrong?
And it isn't only the Fairness Alliance that violates the no-name-calling policy on a regular basis. The media is just as bad. They speak in tongues equally hateful, bigoted, and vulgar, but apparently that is just fine with people Like Jerry Lundergan.
If the Fairness Alliance thinks name calling is wrong, and that saying bad things about people they disagree with is inappropriate, then what about their own behavior.
Physician, heal thyself.
Monday, July 17, 2006
Fair Weather Conservatives
Okay, today we unveil the "Sunshine Aware." The Sunshine Award goes to Kentuckians who claim they are conservatives but, when push comes to shove, act as if their conservative principles don't matter. We'll call them "Fair Weather Conservatives."
We're starting out the list of Kentuckians who claim to be conservatives but really aren't with Bill Stone, a Louisville businessman and former Jefferson County Republican Chairman who voted Thursday, along with most of the other members of the Board of Trustees of the University of Louisville, to give special taxpayer-funded benefits to homosexual and heterosexual live-in "partners".
"I also want to make it clear," Stone told the Louisville Courier-Journal, "this is not an endorsement of gay marriage or any of the other lightning issues. This is simply a recognition that people are people."
Now this comment could qualify Stone for a number of other awards, including the "Foot in the Mouth" award for statements that make absolutely no sense whatsoever. We'll unveil that award later. But for right now we'll just observe that conservatives who act in ways that undermine marriage should have their credentials checked.
We're starting out the list of Kentuckians who claim to be conservatives but really aren't with Bill Stone, a Louisville businessman and former Jefferson County Republican Chairman who voted Thursday, along with most of the other members of the Board of Trustees of the University of Louisville, to give special taxpayer-funded benefits to homosexual and heterosexual live-in "partners".
"I also want to make it clear," Stone told the Louisville Courier-Journal, "this is not an endorsement of gay marriage or any of the other lightning issues. This is simply a recognition that people are people."
Now this comment could qualify Stone for a number of other awards, including the "Foot in the Mouth" award for statements that make absolutely no sense whatsoever. We'll unveil that award later. But for right now we'll just observe that conservatives who act in ways that undermine marriage should have their credentials checked.
Saturday, July 15, 2006
State Universities Diss the General Assembly
In pushing for domestic partner benefits, the state's two major universities have thrown down the gauntlet to the General Assembly. Both the University of Louisville and the University of Kentucky have, through their words and actions, basically told state lawmakers where to get off.
When U of L's board of trustees approved a domestic partner benefits plan at its meeting earlier this week, it ignored past concerns expressed by several state lawmakers in a letter to University of Kentucky President Lee Todd in 2002. The letter addressed a policy then under consideration similar to the one approved this week by U of L.
Now, UK spokesman Jay Blanton has joined the rebellion by telling the Lexington Herald-Leader, "I don't think there are political considerations with respect to this decision." The remark was carefully prefaced by the disclaimer that the university respects "the opinions of legislators"). Yeah, right. They respect their opinions, it's just that their opinions don't make any difference in the university's decision.
When U of L's board of trustees approved a domestic partner benefits plan at its meeting earlier this week, it ignored past concerns expressed by several state lawmakers in a letter to University of Kentucky President Lee Todd in 2002. The letter addressed a policy then under consideration similar to the one approved this week by U of L.
Now, UK spokesman Jay Blanton has joined the rebellion by telling the Lexington Herald-Leader, "I don't think there are political considerations with respect to this decision." The remark was carefully prefaced by the disclaimer that the university respects "the opinions of legislators"). Yeah, right. They respect their opinions, it's just that their opinions don't make any difference in the university's decision.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)